Supplement capsules scattered on a white surface

Our shelf standard

Supplements are not approved by the FDA before they are sold. So we do some of the checking ourselves, and we publish what we find.

Five checks before anything gets shelf space

  1. Check 1

    Label review

    Doses, forms and serving sizes against published research. No proprietary blends.

  2. Check 2

    Test reports

    A current certificate of analysis for identity, potency, heavy metals and microbes.

  3. Check 3

    Certification

    NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Choice or Informed Sport where athletes need it.

  4. Check 4

    Facility

    cGMP manufacturing under FDA 21 CFR Part 111, confirmed with the brand.

  5. Check 5

    Lot log

    Every lot we receive is logged, so we can answer recall questions within the hour.

2026 so far

What our purchasing lead, Ben Arneson, logged from January to October.

Products reviewed
64
Rejected
19
Lots logged
1,412
Recalls affecting us
1

Why products get turned down

Reasons from this year's 19 rejections. Brand names withheld.

Rejection reasons
ReasonCountExample
Proprietary blend hides doses7A pre-workout listing a 9 g "energy matrix" with no amounts
No current test report5Newest certificate was 26 months old
Dose below research range4Ashwagandha at 125 mg when studies use 300 to 600 mg
Label claim we could not support2"Detoxes the liver" on a greens powder
Heavy metals above our limit1Lead in a plant protein above California Prop 65 levels

Check the lot on your bottle

Type the lot number printed near the best-by date and we will show the test report on file.